Market Pressures on Indigenous and Community Lands: Research Atlas
Of 7,045 indexed studies of commercial pressure on Indigenous and community lands, 2,812 (39.9 percent) concern mineral extraction.
The atlas reads 7,045 peer-reviewed studies on how mining, oil and gas, agriculture, timber, tourism, carbon markets and other sectors that sell beyond the community affect the lands, territories, rights, livelihoods and health of Indigenous Peoples and local communities, and on how those effects are governed and contested. Study sites fall in 141 countries. 1,472 studies name at least one specific Indigenous people.
Corpus and method
Every figure on this page counts core studies in the indexed record, unless a caption says otherwise.
Population. A study is core when the relationship between a commercial activity and the lands, territories, resources, rights, livelihoods or health of Indigenous Peoples or local communities is a subject of the study, not background. The activity must serve markets beyond the community. Sectors follow the Land Matrix Initiative's categories of investment intention, with commercial fisheries and aquaculture added. Conservation counts only where control of land or resources passes to an outside actor through a purchase, lease, concession or market scheme. The people concerned follow the term of the Convention on Biological Diversity, Indigenous Peoples and local communities, recorded as each study states it and never inferred.
Selection. Candidates were harvested from OpenAlex (articles, reviews and book chapters with an abstract) by crossing terms for the people concerned with terms for each sector. A small model sorted each candidate into a tier, a stronger model confirmed or changed the tier, and an independent model audited two random draws of 300 candidates: core precision 94.7 and 93.2 percent (95 percent intervals 85.6 to 98.2; 83.8 to 97.3), recall of core from the other tiers 84.8 and 91.4 percent.
| Tier | Studies | Share of candidates |
|---|---|---|
| Core (atlas population) | 7,045 | 21.4% |
| Borderline (held back, not counted) | 6,473 | 19.6% |
| Peripheral | 10,156 | 30.8% |
| Out of scope | 9,264 | 28.1% |
| Unjudged | 10 | 0.0% |
Tags. Each core study was tagged against the shared COMPASS codebook (version 2.0) by a panel of domain-expert prompts. A tag is kept only if its value is in the codebook, its evidence is found in the abstract, and a second model confirms it; a third model then re-checked every kept tag and removed the ones it rejected. A blind check by a fourth model, on 120 random tags from each of five batches, judged 480 of 600 tags correct, 80.0 percent (95 percent interval 76.6 to 83.0). About one tag in five is therefore wrong; counts built from tags carry that error.
Studies by sector
A study can concern several sectors; 1,485 of the 7,045 core studies (21 percent) concern more than one.
Extractive sectors dominate: mineral extraction and oil and gas together appear in 3,854 sector assignments, against 541 for carbon trading and 442 for conservation deals. Livestock (128), biofuels (87) and industrial zones (82) carry the fewest studies.
Studies by people concerned
Each core study records whether it concerns Indigenous Peoples, local communities, or both, as the study itself states it.
| Sector | Studies | Indigenous Peoples | Local communities | Both | Share concerning Indigenous Peoples |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mineral extraction | 2,812 | 1,447 | 1,104 | 261 | 61% |
| Agriculture | 1,319 | 493 | 647 | 179 | 51% |
| Oil and gas | 1,042 | 635 | 304 | 103 | 71% |
| Timber | 768 | 352 | 316 | 100 | 59% |
| Tourism | 663 | 263 | 365 | 35 | 45% |
| Carbon trading | 541 | 198 | 233 | 110 | 57% |
| Fisheries and aquaculture | 496 | 214 | 238 | 44 | 52% |
| Renewable energy | 452 | 236 | 183 | 33 | 60% |
| Conservation deals | 442 | 163 | 229 | 50 | 48% |
| Livestock | 128 | 83 | 24 | 21 | 81% |
| Biofuels | 87 | 18 | 54 | 15 | 38% |
| Industry | 82 | 46 | 32 | 4 | 61% |
Across all sectors, 3,990 core studies (57 percent) concern Indigenous Peoples, alone or with local communities. The share is highest for livestock (81 percent) and lowest for biofuels (38 percent).
Named Indigenous peoples
Specific peoples named in the 3,990 core studies that concern Indigenous Peoples; 1,472 of them name at least one.
A model listed each people a study names in its title or abstract, with a quote that had to be found in the text; collective labels such as "Indigenous peoples", "First Nations" or "Aboriginal peoples" are not counted. Each name was then matched to Glottolog 5.3, the reference catalogue of the world's languages, where a match fits the study; names left unmatched are kept as the study writes them. A blind check of 100 studies found 93.2 percent of extracted names correct (95 percent interval 88.3 to 96.2), 97.4 percent of named peoples found (93.6 to 99.0), and 95.0 percent of Glottolog matches correct (89.5 to 97.7). Glottolog names languages, so the table shows the people by the name the studies use most, with the language entry beside it.
| People (as the studies name it) | Glottolog entry | Studies | Countries |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sámi | Saami saam1281 | 59 | Finland, Norway, Sweden |
| Mapuche | Mapudungun mapu1245 | 30 | Argentina, Chile |
| Dayak | not matched | 28 | Indonesia, Malaysia |
| Inuit | Inuit inui1246 | 28 | Canada |
| Māori | Maori maor1246 | 26 | New Zealand |
| Maasai | Masai masa1300 | 17 | Kenya, Tanzania |
| Navajo | Navajo nava1243 | 17 | United States |
| Yanomami | not matched | 15 | Brazil |
| Anishinaabe | not matched | 14 | Canada, United States |
| Atacameño | Kunza kunz1244 | 14 | Argentina, Chile |
| Wayuu | Wayuu wayu1243 | 14 | Colombia |
| Kichwa | not matched | 13 | Ecuador, Peru |
| Maya | Mayan maya1287 | 13 | Belize, Guatemala, Mexico |
| Nenets | Nenets nene1251 | 13 | Russia |
| Waorani | Waorani waor1240 | 12 | Ecuador |
| Haida | Haida haid1248 | 11 | Canada, United States |
| Standing Rock Sioux | not matched | 11 | United States |
| Cree | Cree cree1272 | 10 | Canada |
| Marind | not matched | 10 | Indonesia |
| Mi'kmaq | Mi'kmaq mikm1235 | 10 | Canada |
| Ogoni | Ogonoid ogon1240 | 10 | Nigeria |
| Orang Rimba | not matched | 10 | Indonesia |
| Heiltsuk | Heiltsuk-Oowekyala heil1246 | 9 | Canada |
| Métis | not matched | 8 | Canada |
| Oraon | not matched | 8 | India |
| Tłı̨chǫ | Dogrib dogr1252 | 8 | Canada |
| Dene | not matched | 7 | Canada |
| Kayapó | Mebengokre kaya1330 | 7 | Brazil |
| Munduruku | Mundurukú mund1330 | 7 | Brazil |
| Shuar | Shuar shua1257 | 7 | Ecuador |
The 2,047 names cover 873 matched to 347 Glottolog entries; the rest are not matched. Some name a subgroup, a nation or a community (Ngāti Awa, Standing Rock Sioux) rather than a language group; others are peoples Glottolog does list that the matching step missed (Yanomami, Anishinaabe), so an unmatched name is not a statement that no entry exists. The blind check measured the correctness of matches made, not how many fitting entries were missed.
Governance, actors and effects studied
The companies, states, markets and rules through which the pressure arrives, and its effects on the people concerned, from the codebook tags of the core studies.
Customary and Indigenous rights (2,387 studies) and land acquisition and concessions (1,252) are the mechanisms most studied. Market-side rules are rare in the record: certification and voluntary standards appear in 149 core studies, corporate due diligence and supply-chain rules in 127, and trade and investment policy in 41.
Companies (2,601 studies) and states (3,069) are studied far more often than the investors who finance them (95) or the consumer markets that buy from them (26).
Effects studied by sector
Share of each sector's core studies carrying each social dimension tag.
| Sector | Studies | Dispossession and Displacement | Socio-environmental Conflict | Community Response and Resistance | Environmental Justice | Livelihoods and Wellbeing | Health and Environment | Gender and Social Differentiation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mineral extraction | 2,812 | 7% | 9% | 7% | 11% | 4% | 1% | 1% |
| Agriculture | 1,319 | 8% | 6% | 4% | 9% | 6% | 1% | 2% |
| Oil and gas | 1,042 | 6% | 9% | 7% | 9% | 4% | 1% | 1% |
| Timber | 768 | 7% | 8% | 5% | 8% | 5% | 0% | 1% |
| Tourism | 663 | 5% | 6% | 7% | 10% | 6% | 0% | 1% |
| Carbon trading | 541 | 5% | 3% | 7% | 11% | 5% | 0% | 2% |
| Fisheries and aquaculture | 496 | 5% | 6% | 11% | 7% | 7% | 0% | 1% |
| Renewable energy | 452 | 5% | 9% | 8% | 8% | 5% | 0% | 1% |
| Conservation deals | 442 | 6% | 7% | 9% | 10% | 6% | 0% | 2% |
| Livestock | 128 | 5% | 5% | 5% | 13% | 6% | 0% | 3% |
| Biofuels | 87 | 10% | 5% | 0% | 13% | 9% | 1% | 1% |
| Industry | 82 | 7% | 5% | 5% | 6% | 6% | 0% | 1% |
Gender and social differentiation is tagged on 89 core studies (1.3 percent) and health on 50 (0.7 percent), against 426 (6 percent) for dispossession and displacement.
Study designs and methods
How the core studies obtain their evidence, from the study type and social-science method tags.
Qualitative and documentary studies (2,813) and literature reviews (1,071) make up most of the record; field studies number 101 and modelling studies 88. Policy, legal and document analysis is the most common method (2,147 studies), ethnographic fieldwork appears in 403, participatory and community-based methods in 371, and research led or co-produced by Indigenous Peoples in 57 (0.8 percent of core studies).
Study-site countries
5,132 of 7,045 core studies (73 percent) have at least one located study site, at 3,480 distinct places in 141 countries. A study can have sites in several countries.
For where research sits against coverage cells and access distances, see section 9; for the same sites set against environmental change and split by decade, section 10.
Five countries (Indonesia, Canada, Australia, Brazil, India) hold 2,472 of the 5,571 study-country pairs (44 percent). Indonesia alone has 1,196 studies; its most-studied sector is agriculture.
| Country | Studies with a site there | Most-studied sector |
|---|---|---|
| Indonesia | 1,196 | Agriculture |
| Canada | 506 | Mineral extraction |
| Australia | 279 | Mineral extraction |
| Brazil | 277 | Mineral extraction |
| India | 214 | Mineral extraction |
| United States | 180 | Oil and gas |
| Peru | 140 | Mineral extraction |
| Chile | 133 | Mineral extraction |
| Nigeria | 129 | Oil and gas |
| Ecuador | 126 | Oil and gas |
| Mexico | 119 | Renewable energy |
| Russia | 117 | Mineral extraction |
| Colombia | 108 | Mineral extraction |
| Philippines | 87 | Mineral extraction |
| Malaysia | 82 | Agriculture |
| Kenya | 75 | Conservation deals |
| South Africa | 72 | Mineral extraction |
| Ghana | 71 | Mineral extraction |
| Argentina | 69 | Mineral extraction |
| Papua New Guinea | 68 | Mineral extraction |
Geographic distribution of study sites
5,132 of 7,045 studies name a locatable study site; where those sites fall, and how far they sit from the nearest large city.
1 · Where the study sites are
Each cell is one hexagon of the H3 grid, drawn on its true boundary so that the cells tile without overlap; darker cells hold more distinct study sites. Most cells hold one site; the fieldwork of the whole corpus concentrates in a small number of them.
The densest window, enlarged
The dashed rectangle on the map above marks the window that holds the most study sites (94°E to 148°E, 14°S to 14°N). Here it is at a larger scale and at the grid's own resolution 3 (about 12,400 km2 per cell), with its own log ramp.
2 · How far the sites are from a city
Distance from each study site to the nearest populated place of 100,000 people or more is a rough measure of how reachable the fieldwork was. The busiest access points, counted greedily so that no site is counted twice, are Salatiga (Indonesia, 40 sites within 100 km), Denpasar (Indonesia, 31 sites within 100 km), Mojokerto (Indonesia, 29 sites within 100 km); 9.0% of all sites lie within 100 km of one of the ten busiest.
These are straight-line distances, not travel times; roads, terrain, sea ice and protected-area access are not modelled. Study-site coordinates are geoparsed from abstracts, and region-level places sit at their centroid.
3 · Method note
Sources. access points = Natural Earth ne_10m_populated_places_simple, GitHub master 5.2.0-pre (nvkelso/natural-earth-vector, downloaded 2026-09-29) (populated places with 100,000 people or more), public domain; grid = H3 resolution 3 (h3-js 4.5.0), drawn on the true cell boundaries from h3-js and aggregated one level (h3 cellToParent) on the main maps. A study site is a place a paper's abstract names as the location of the work, resolved to coordinates by a gazetteer and kept only when it came from one of the six trusted geocode sources; 5,132 of 7,045 studies (72.8%) have one. Density and distance use precise sites only (not a whole country, not a rounded centroid): 2,533 distinct places.
Caveat. Study-site coordinates come from automated geoparsing; a 40-site manual check found 31 plausible; a 100 to 200 pin human check is planned.
Provenance. Generated 2026-10-28 from the published database. Figures in this section are recomputed by phase1/spatial_shortfall.js and checked by the figures audit.
4 · Explore these layers
The coverage cells are a layer on the interactive map, switched on when you open it from here, with the study sites and this atlas's tag filters underneath. Any country, ecoregion, administrative region or drawn area can be queried against the whole database in the place explorer, which lists the papers inside it and the topics that are thin there.
Research against change
Three questions of the same study sites: where the environment is changing fastest with the least located research, whether research effort tracks change at all (it does not: the correlation is near zero), and when the located research was published. 31 of 290 ecoregions sit in the high-change, low-research quadrant for forest loss.
In this corpus the rate of environmental change and the density of located research are essentially unrelated: Spearman's rank correlation between the two, unit by unit, is near zero. For forest loss it is −0.022 across 290 ecoregions and 0.048 across 1,042 states and provinces; for drying it is −0.100 across 237 ecoregions and −0.113 across 770 states and provinces. These are descriptive figures: they do not show that change causes or deters research, and the units differ in area, accessibility. What they do show is where fast change and little located research coincide, which is the list each block below ranks.
1 · Forest loss 2001 to 2024
Change here is the share of the area that was forest in 2000 (tree cover of 30 percent or more) with a loss event between 2001 and 2024, from Hansen Global Forest Change v1.12 at 30 m. Each ecoregion (an area of broadly similar natural vegetation and climate, from the RESOLVE 2017 ecoregion map) and each state or province (the first level of division inside a country: a state, province, region or its equivalent, from GADM 4.1) is placed in one of four quadrants: the top third of the universe by forest loss is high change, the bottom third by located research density (papers of this corpus with a precise study site inside the unit, per 10,000 km2) is low research. The high-change, low-research quadrant is the candidate gap list.
Loss is any stand-replacing event, including fire and the rotational harvest of plantations, and regrowth is not subtracted, so a high value can be a working plantation landscape as easily as a cleared forest; the 30 percent canopy threshold makes open woodland "not forest".
| Ecoregion | Country | Forest lost | Papers with a site | Per 10,000 km2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Northern Khorat Plateau moist deciduous forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Thailand, Laos | 42.9%26% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Peninsular Malaysian peat swamp forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Malaysia | 42.9%91% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Knysna-Amatole montane forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | South Africa | 32.8%70% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Mato Grosso tropical dry forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Brazil | 28.8%76% forested in 2000 | 4 | 0.10 |
| Chiquitano dry forestsTropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | Bolivia, Brazil | 28.4%78% forested in 2000 | 2 | 0.09 |
| Xingu-Tocantins-Araguaia moist forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Brazil | 27.8%85% forested in 2000 | 2 | 0.08 |
| Madagascar dry deciduous forestsTropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | Madagascar | 27.6%19% forested in 2000 | 1 | 0.07 |
| South China-Vietnam subtropical evergreen forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | China, Vietnam | 26.8%39% forested in 2000 | 2 | 0.09 |
| Guinean montane forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Guinea, Côte d'Ivoire, Sierra Leone | 26.7%45% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Madagascar mangrovesMangroves | Madagascar | 26.1%29% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| State or province | Country | Forest lost | Papers with a site | Per 10,000 km2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bình Dương | Vietnam | 78.9%36% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Melaka | Malaysia | 61.0%69% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Krâchéh | Cambodia | 56.2%58% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Kâmpóng Thum | Cambodia | 56.2%54% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Kâmpóng Cham | Cambodia | 55.3%16% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Amnat Charoen | Thailand | 53.2%12% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Atlantique | Benin | 52.0%5% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Negeri Sembilan | Malaysia | 50.8%84% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Kindia | Guinea | 50.7%45% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
| Tbong Khmum | Cambodia | 50.2%29% forested in 2000 | 0 | 0.00 |
Forest loss 2001 to 2024, cell by cell
2 · Aridity trend 1990 to 2024
Change here is the linear trend of the annual aridity index (precipitation over potential evapotranspiration, P/PET) from 1990 to 2024, as percent change per decade of the 1990 to 1999 mean, from TerraClimate at about 4.6 km; a negative number means drying. Each ecoregion (an area of broadly similar natural vegetation and climate, from the RESOLVE 2017 ecoregion map) and each state or province (the first level of division inside a country: a state, province, region or its equivalent, from GADM 4.1) is placed in one of four quadrants: the top third of the universe by drying is high change, the bottom third by located research density (papers of this corpus with a precise study site inside the unit, per 10,000 km2) is low research. The high-change, low-research quadrant is the candidate gap list.
TerraClimate is an interpolated climate surface, so a 35-year trend at 4 km carries station-density and interpolation error, and a relative trend is unstable where the baseline is near zero; the ranking is restricted to drylands (mean P/PET under 0.65) and excludes hyper-arid units (mean under 0.05) for that reason.
| Ecoregion | Country | Aridity trend | Papers with a site | Per 10,000 km2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Khangai Mountains alpine meadowMontane Grasslands & Shrublands | Mongolia | −9.8%dry sub-humid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Gobi Lakes Valley desert steppeDeserts & Xeric Shrublands | Mongolia | −9.6%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Caspian lowland desertDeserts & Xeric Shrublands | Kazakhstan, Russia, Turkmenistan, Iran | −9.5%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Knysna-Amatole montane forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | South Africa | −9.2%dry sub-humid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Namaqualand-Richtersveld steppeDeserts & Xeric Shrublands | South Africa, Namibia | −8.6%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Succulent Karoo xeric shrublandsDeserts & Xeric Shrublands | South Africa | −8.6%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Khangai Mountains conifer forestsTemperate Conifer Forests | Mongolia | −8.5%semi-arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Edwards Plateau savannaTemperate Grasslands, Savannas & Shrublands | United States | −8.2%semi-arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Canary Islands dry woodlands and forestsMediterranean Forests, Woodlands & Scrub | Spain | −8.1%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| North Arabian highland shrublandsDeserts & Xeric Shrublands | Saudi Arabia | −8.1%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| State or province | Country | Aridity trend | Papers with a site | Per 10,000 km2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lakes | South Sudan | −13.0%dry sub-humid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Mendoza | Argentina | −12.8%semi-arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Biskra | Algeria | −12.8%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Central Equatoria | South Sudan | −12.8%dry sub-humid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Córdoba | Argentina | −12.2%dry sub-humid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Govi-Altay | Mongolia | −12.1%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| San Luis | Argentina | −12.1%semi-arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Misratah | Libya | −12.1%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| La Rioja | Argentina | −11.4%arid | 0 | 0.00 |
| Kalmyk | Russia | −11.3%semi-arid | 0 | 0.00 |
Aridity trend 1990 to 2024, cell by cell
3 · When the research happened
The same study sites split by decade of publication. Of the 2,689 located papers, 91.1% were published in the 2010s or 2020s and 75.6% since 2016. The whole corpus of 7,045 papers, located or not, is 90.3% from those two decades, so located research is about as recent as the corpus. Of the 454 ecoregions with a located paper, 17 have none published since 2010; of the 706 states and provinces, 29. 9 located papers have no publication year.
The decade with the most located papers, cell by cell
4 · Method note
Change layers. Forest loss 2001 to 2024 = UMD/hansen/global_forest_change_2024_v1_12 (v1.12 (2024 update)), 2001-2024, sampled at 30 m (native 30 m), CC BY 4.0; Aridity trend 1990 to 2024 = IDAHO_EPSCOR/TERRACLIMATE (TerraClimate monthly, EE catalogue copy (1958-01 to 2024-12 at run time)), 1990-2024, sampled at 4,638 m (native 4,638 m), TerraClimate: CC0 1.0 (public domain). MODIS: NASA, no restrictions; dryland classes after UNEP 1992. Values are computed in Google Earth Engine over each H3 cell of the grid (the maps above draw them one resolution coarser, as valid-area-weighted means of the child cells) and each unit outline (RESOLVE Ecoregions 2017 and GADM 4.1, simplified for display); boundary pixels are weighted fractionally. Forest loss sums every 30 m pixel by its area for cells and units up to 25,000 km2; a larger unit is estimated from 1,000 windows of about 1 km2 placed at random inside it, each measured at 30 m. The other layers are area means of a systematic sample at their native resolution. Layers are remote-sensing and reanalysis products, not field measurements.
Revision. Forest loss was recomputed on 28 October 2026 at the native 30 m resolution. The earlier version averaged tree cover and loss to a coarser grid before applying the 30 percent forest threshold, which overstated loss in mixed and fragmented landscapes; the order of units changed little (rank correlation 0.94 to 0.98 between versions), but individual values fell, most in plantation and mosaic regions.
Research. 2,689 of 7,045 papers in this corpus have a precise trusted study site (the same selection as the density map above); a paper counts once per cell and once per unit it has a site in, and a unit's density is papers per 10,000 km2 of its area. Only units of 1,000 km2 or more are ranked, so that a city-state's density is not set against a province's. 20 precise places (open sea, Southern Ocean, atoll centroids) fall in no ecoregion and 11 in no state or province; they are in the cell maps but not in the unit tables.
Reading it. A near-zero correlation says that, across these units, more change does not go with more or with less located research. It does not say that change deters research or that research prevents change, and units differ in area, accessibility, national research capacity. A unit in the high-change, low-research quadrant is a candidate gap, not a proven one. Papers whose text names no locatable site are invisible here: a study whose question is not tied to a place, such as a global, laboratory, trade-flow, policy or review paper, counts in the corpus total above but has no site to place in any unit, so absence of a located study is not absence of research. The geoparsing caveat of the section above applies.
Provenance. Generated 2026-11-03 from the published database and the Earth Engine cache. Figures in this section are recomputed by phase1/research_vs_change.js, drawn by phase1/gen_atlas_change_section.js and checked by the figures audit.
5 · Explore these layers
These layers are on the interactive map as forest loss 2001 to 2024 and aridity trend 1990 to 2024, cell by cell with the value and the located papers on hover, and a decade selector that limits the study-site dots to one decade of publication.
Expected research Beta
How much located research would each place be expected to carry, given its size, access, environmental change, biome and national research effort, and where the record falls short of that expectation. Cross-validated pseudo-R2 0.66 for ecoregions and 0.49 for states and provinces. Experimental: a first statistical model, still under test and stated with its interval and its limits. The sections above do not depend on it.
Beta This section fits a model of research attention: the number of papers of this corpus with a precise study site inside each ecoregion (an area of broadly similar natural vegetation and climate, from the RESOLVE 2017 ecoregion map) and each state or province (the first level of division inside a country: a state, province, region or its equivalent, from GADM 4.1), predicted from the unit's area, its distance to the nearest city of 100,000 people, forest loss and the aridity trend, its biome, realm and latitude band, and how much located research the rest of its country carries. The model predicts where research tends to go. It does not predict ecological importance, threat or need, and a unit with less research than expected is a candidate gap: a place where the record is thinner than in comparable places. It is never proof of neglect. Fit quality is measured out of sample by 5-fold spatial cross-validation (whole realms or whole countries held out): pseudo-R2 0.66 for ecoregions and 0.49 for states and provinces. Each unit carries a 90 percent prediction interval from the negative-binomial count spread about its expectation. Located research is strongly clustered, so that interval is wide, and in this run no unit falls below it. The rankings therefore order units by the tail probability, the chance of a count at or under the observed one given the expectation, and carry the interval label alongside.
1 · Ecoregions: expected against observed Beta
Fit. 777 ecoregions in the universe, 451 with a located paper; negative binomial, dispersion theta 0.90, mean by Poisson quasi-likelihood, ridge lambda 100. 5-fold spatial cross-validation blocked by realm: pseudo-R2 0.66 (0.35 without the national-effort covariate), Spearman rho 0.65 out of fold. Labels against the 90 percent interval: 0 below, 744 within, 33 above.
| Ecoregion | Country | Observed | Expected, 90% interval | Tail probability | Label |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Borneo montane rain forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Indonesia, Malaysia | 1 | 27.3090%: 1 to 86 | 0.085 | within |
| Somali Acacia-Commiphora bushlands and thicketsTropical & Subtropical Grasslands, Savannas & Shrublands | Ethiopia, Somalia, Kenya | 0 | 12.8390%: 0 to 41 | 0.086 | within |
| Vogelkop montane rain forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Indonesia | 0 | 11.4990%: 0 to 37 | 0.095 | within |
| Luang Prabang montane rain forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Laos, Thailand, Vietnam | 0 | 10.4390%: 0 to 33 | 0.103 | within |
| Northeast Congolian lowland forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Congo - Kinshasa, Central African Republic | 0 | 8.0590%: 0 to 26 | 0.127 | within |
| Central Deccan Plateau dry deciduous forestsTropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | India | 1 | 14.5790%: 0 to 46 | 0.143 | within |
| Sri Lanka dry-zone dry evergreen forestsTropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | Sri Lanka | 0 | 5.9190%: 0 to 19 | 0.162 | within |
| Southern Hudson Bay taigaBoreal Forests/Taiga | Canada | 0 | 5.8890%: 0 to 19 | 0.163 | within |
| Seram rain forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Indonesia | 1 | 11.2890%: 0 to 36 | 0.176 | within |
| Ogilvie-MacKenzie alpine tundraTundra | Canada, United States | 0 | 5.1590%: 0 to 17 | 0.180 | within |
| Ecoregion | Country | Observed | Expected, 90% interval | Tail probability | Label |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fiji tropical moist forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Fiji | 5 | 0.1790%: 0 to 1 | under 0.001 | above |
| Southern Pacific dry forestsTropical & Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests | Mexico | 30 | 2.6290%: 0 to 9 | under 0.001 | above |
| Caatinga Enclaves moist forestsTropical & Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests | Brazil | 6 | 0.3290%: 0 to 2 | under 0.001 | above |
| Arnhem Land tropical savannaTropical & Subtropical Grasslands, Savannas & Shrublands | Australia | 31 | 3.2290%: 0 to 11 | under 0.001 | above |
| Queen Charlotte Islands conifer forestsTemperate Conifer Forests | Canada | 8 | 0.6390%: 0 to 3 | 0.001 | above |
The "more than expected" list doubles as a geocoding audit: a small unit with tens of papers against an expectation under one is as likely a place-name collision, a herbarium or a field station as a genuine concentration of fieldwork.
2 · States and provinces: expected against observed Beta
Fit. 2,715 states and provinces in the universe, 686 with a located paper; negative binomial, dispersion theta 0.64, mean by Poisson quasi-likelihood, ridge lambda 30. 5-fold spatial cross-validation blocked by country: pseudo-R2 0.49 (0.32 without the national-effort covariate), Spearman rho 0.53 out of fold. Labels against the 90 percent interval: 0 below, 2,637 within, 78 above.
| State or province | Country | Observed | Expected, 90% interval | Tail probability | Label |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kalimantan Utara | Indonesia | 2 | 20.5190%: 0 to 73 | 0.226 | within |
| Uttar Pradesh | India | 1 | 13.1290%: 0 to 47 | 0.226 | within |
| Coahuila | México | 0 | 5.4390%: 0 to 20 | 0.237 | within |
| Oregon | United States | 0 | 5.3790%: 0 to 20 | 0.239 | within |
| East Sepik | Papua New Guinea | 0 | 5.1490%: 0 to 19 | 0.245 | within |
| Bihar | India | 0 | 5.0490%: 0 to 19 | 0.247 | within |
| Somali | Ethiopia | 0 | 4.5990%: 0 to 17 | 0.261 | within |
| Idaho | United States | 0 | 4.3490%: 0 to 16 | 0.269 | within |
| Caquetá | Colombia | 0 | 4.3290%: 0 to 16 | 0.270 | within |
| Tocantins | Brazil | 0 | 4.3090%: 0 to 16 | 0.271 | within |
| State or province | Country | Observed | Expected, 90% interval | Tail probability | Label |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alba | Romania | 11 | 0.0290%: 0 to 0 | under 0.001 | above |
| Iburengerazuba | Rwanda | 5 | 0.0390%: 0 to 0 | under 0.001 | above |
| Taiwan | Taiwan | 7 | 0.1290%: 0 to 1 | under 0.001 | above |
| Brokopondo | Suriname | 4 | 0.0490%: 0 to 0 | under 0.001 | above |
| Ulaanbaatar | Mongolia | 3 | 0.0490%: 0 to 0 | under 0.001 | above |
The "more than expected" list doubles as a geocoding audit: a small unit with tens of papers against an expectation under one is as likely a place-name collision, a herbarium or a field station as a genuine concentration of fieldwork.
3 · Calibration
Out of fold, by decile of expected count (observed / expected): ecoregions: deciles 3 to 8 between 0.89 and 1.79, top decile 1.28; states and provinces: deciles 3 to 8 between 0.55 and 0.98, top decile 1.20. The middle deciles are the best calibrated; the top decile is under-predicted in every model, because the busiest places (long-term field stations, provinces with a herbarium or a university) exceed what any smooth covariate model gives. That is one more reason the residuals are candidate gaps and candidate artefacts rather than findings.
4 · Method note Beta
Response and exposure. 2,689 of 7,045 papers in this corpus have a precise trusted study site (38.2 percent); the response per unit is the number of those papers with a site inside it (point in polygon, or the nearest unit within 25 km, as the place explorer counts), so a paper with sites in two units counts once in each: 3,115 unit-papers over 777 ecoregions and 2,935 over 2,715 states and provinces (of 847 and 3,686 units in all). The exposure is log(area), with log(area) also entering as a slope so the data set the area elasticity.
Covariates. log_area_km2, log_access_km, forest_loss_pct, forest_loss_missing, aridity_trend_pct_per_decade, aridity_trend_missing, log_national_loo_density, national_loo_undefined, biome, realm, lat_band; continuous covariates standardised, categorical levels with fewer than 10 units pooled. Protected-area share is not available (no protected-area table in the database) and is stated as the natural next covariate.
Model and validation. Negative binomial (NB2) GLM with a log link and a ridge penalty on the standardised slopes (ecoregions lambda 100, states and provinces lambda 30); the mean estimator and lambda are chosen on out-of-fold Poisson deviance over the same spatial folds; the dispersion is estimated by maximum likelihood. 5-fold spatial cross-validation blocked by realm (ecoregions) or country (states and provinces), never random rows; a held-out realm's own dummy is unseen in training. The 90 percent interval is the 5th and 95th percentile of NB(expected, theta) and carries no parameter uncertainty, so it is if anything too narrow. Zero rule: a unit with no located paper and an expectation under 0.5 is never labelled below and never ranked.
Limits. Located papers only: papers whose text names no locatable site are invisible here, and the geoparsing error rate of the sections above applies. The national-effort covariate carries most of the between-country signal; the fit without it is printed above. Terrestrial units only. This is a Beta layer: the numbers are honest as stated, and they will move when the geocoding, the corpus or the covariates change.
Provenance. Generated 2026-10-29 from the published database (SELECT only) and the change layers' cache. Refresh with node phase1/expected_research.js market-pressures, redraw with phase1/gen_atlas_expected_section.js; every figure in this section is checked by the figures audit.
5 · Explore this layer
The same units are on the interactive map as the beta layer "Expected vs observed", ecoregions or states and provinces, with observed, expected, interval and label on hover, and a link from each unit to the place explorer. The place explorer shows the same figures for a selected unit under "Beta: expected research".
Studies by half-decade of publication
5,493 of the 7,045 core studies (78 percent) were published in 2015 or later.
The last half-decade is incomplete: it holds studies published from 2025 to the October 2026 harvest.